| Author |
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
Anyone else agree that these are the days of our lives feels like its unfinished? its so empty and lacking something, thats why we improved it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_pfoWaIrfU
|
thomasquinn 32989
Deity: 6313 posts
|
Unfinished? You must be joking. So, you ruined the intro with a few gratuitous (and utterly useless) piano notes, and you copied the synth-pad track on digital piano and mixed that onto the track. The only thing you managed to achieve was a complete destruction of the serene spaciousness of the track.
Not Plutus but Apollo rules Parnassus
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
ThomasQuinn wrote:
Unfinished? You must be joking.
no it feels unfinished, as if things are missing instrumentally.
|
thomasquinn 32989
Deity: 6313 posts
|
Treasure Moment wrote:
ThomasQuinn wrote:
Unfinished? You must be joking.
no it feels unfinished, as if things are missing instrumentally. You added nothing except for a carbon copy of the synth pads and a few chord-tones in the intro!
Not Plutus but Apollo rules Parnassus
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
ThomasQuinn wrote: Treasure Moment wrote:
ThomasQuinn wrote:
Unfinished? You must be joking.
no it feels unfinished, as if things are missing instrumentally. You added nothing except for a carbon copy of the synth pads and a few chord-tones in the intro! Its like 2 new instruments added, i know it already has some strings but you can barely hear them, that "nothing" does ALOT for this song, its strings plus piano AND a whole new piano solo.
|
thomasquinn 32989
Deity: 6313 posts
|
...which does nothing except thicken the orchestration. And your 'solo' consists of a few unimaginative chord-tones.
Not Plutus but Apollo rules Parnassus
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
ThomasQuinn wrote:
...which does nothing except thicken the orchestration. And your 'solo' consists of a few unimaginative chord-tones.
yes it thickens it and thats the point, as for the solo i dont care what you say, it fits the song perfectly, my brother did that.
|
thomasquinn 32989
Deity: 6313 posts
|
Treasure Moment wrote:
ThomasQuinn wrote:
...which does nothing except thicken the orchestration. And your 'solo' consists of a few unimaginative chord-tones.
yes it thickens it and thats the point, as for the solo i dont care what you say, it fits the song perfectly, my brother did that. Thickening the orchestration serves no purpose whatsoever here, as there is no thinly orchestrated section to contrast it to. Disregarding for a moment that the synth strings and piano take up roughly the same section of the acoustic spectrum here (and thus drown each other out), the added piano track would have little or no perceptible result. You seem to think that anything that sounds consonant and boring suits the song, and you obsessively tell us that you are sheer genius, but you still come up with the same kind of junk as a year ago. You are not improving, if only because you are too arrogant to learn from anything or anyone.
Not Plutus but Apollo rules Parnassus
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
ThomasQuinn wrote: Treasure Moment wrote:
ThomasQuinn wrote:
...which does nothing except thicken the orchestration. And your 'solo' consists of a few unimaginative chord-tones.
yes it thickens it and thats the point, as for the solo i dont care what you say, it fits the song perfectly, my brother did that. Thickening the orchestration serves no purpose whatsoever here, as there is no thinly orchestrated section to contrast it to. Disregarding for a moment that the synth strings and piano take up roughly the same section of the acoustic spectrum here (and thus drown each other out), the added piano track would have little or no perceptible result. You seem to think that anything that sounds consonant and boring suits the song, and you obsessively tell us that you are sheer genius, but you still come up with the same kind of junk as a year ago. You are not improving, if only because you are too arrogant to learn from anything or anyone. Say what you want, all that matters is that i KNOW that it makes the song alot better, its about feeling, the song was empty as it was.
|
thomasquinn 32989
Deity: 6313 posts
|
And with those words, you again condemn yourself to a life of mediocrity. You just refuse to be the least bit critical of yourself, and that is the worst trait a musician could possibly have.
Not Plutus but Apollo rules Parnassus
|
cmsdrums
Deity: 3147 posts
|
To me, TATDOOL (along with, let's be frank, virtually all of Queen's catalogue) is perfect in it's arrangement, production, and thought as to what is and isn't in the final mix. Whether any of us actually like specific songs is however always open to questions of personal preference, but the view that this track, or any others, are not complete arrangement-wise simply cannot be justified. I haven't listened to your mix, but don't need to know that it doesn't improve on the original - the most that you could say about it is that it is a different version/mix.
|
|
Marcos Napier
Bohemian: 625 posts
|
Say what you want, all that matters is that i KNOW that it makes the song
alot better, its about feeling, the song was empty as it was. I heard they are looking for a replacement for Paul. You should apply.
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
cmsdrums wrote:
To me, TATDOOL (along with, let's be frank, virtually all of Queen's catalogue) is perfect in it's arrangement, production, and thought as to what is and isn't in the final mix. Whether any of us actually like specific songs is however always open to questions of personal preference, but the view that this track, or any others, are not complete arrangement-wise simply cannot be justified.
I haven't listened to your mix, but don't need to know that it doesn't improve on the original - the most that you could say about it is that it is a different version/mix. check it out, trust me its better than the original and remember that is the only song i think is unfinished.
|
Negative Creep
Bohemian: 728 posts
|
If you think you've improved the song it in any way, you're delusional. I have a feeling the band had a better idea how they wanted the song to sound.... than you! I'm also pretty sure no ones gives a fuck whether you think the song is unfinished.
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
Negative Creep wrote:
If you think you've improved the song it in any way, you're delusional. I have a feeling the band had a better idea how they wanted the song to sound.... than you! I'm also pretty sure no ones gives a fuck whether you think the song is unfinished. and im sure no one gives a fuck what you think either specially when you know shit about music and what can be improved or not.
|
Negative Creep
Bohemian: 728 posts
|
Well, I'm real sure lots of people are listening to "your" music. Maybe Brian should start getting in touch with you, so you can help improve all his recordings for him!
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
Negative Creep wrote:
Well, I'm real sure lots of people are listening to "your" music. Maybe Brian should start getting in touch with you, so you can help improve all his recordings for him! im just talking about this particular song, it feels unfinished.
|
onevsion
Deity: 2241 posts
|
|
Treasure Moment
Deity: 3413 posts
|
Ducksoup wrote: hahaha... funny guy. Not really, just telling facts.
|
Raf
Stop this noise!
Deity: 8274 posts
|
Paul Rodgers improves Queen songs. You ruin them.
We got the Cosmos rockin'!
We got the Cosmos rockin'!
We got the Universe rockin'!
We got the Cosmos rockin'!
We got the Cosmos rockin' to the mighty power of rock'n'roll!
|
