| Author |
|
Zander05
Bohemian: 860 posts
|
Hmm. Not too sure about the guitar work... I know it takes a lot of guts to present a cover. For that, I say good job. But having listened to it, I'm not too wild about it. I've heard better.
|
Farlander
Bohemian: 662 posts
|
Well, not horrible, but definately not excellent. The main problem is that there's an attitude to this song, a groove, and this recording doesn't have it. It's too straight.
|
FriedChicken
Deity: 10641 posts
|
Finally a new fan song...good work Richard! :-D I like it Hope to hear more fan songs soon
"On the first day Pim & Niek created a heavenly occupation. Pim & Niek blessed it and named it 'Loosch'."
(Genesis 1:1)
|
Sebastian
Deity: 6568 posts
|
You didn`t do it like them, you did it like you and that`s the idea imho. Whoever wants to hear a version exactly like the Queen one can easily put the Game, track #5 (if I remember correctly) and enjoy. Nice version, the guitarist style is very similar to a friend of mine. Maybe that`s him, since I never knew what happened to that bloke :) The world is a serviette
John hated Hot Space. Fred's favourite singer was not Paul Rodgers. Roger didn't compose 'Innuendo.' Witness testimonies are often inaccurate. Wales is not in England. 'Bo Rhap' hasn't got 180 voices.
|
Koolkikiland
Champion: 71 posts
|
Richard Orchard wrote: I really think that you guys are unrealistic in your expectations. I agree. I'm guessing most fans aren't full-time recording artists and are doing this only for fun out of their small home studio setups. No one that I'm aware of is doing this to compete with anyone else or even to get any critiques. It's just a way of expressing a love for Queen music. With this cover, yeah, compared to professional recording standards (especially those of Queen) it has it's areas for improvement. Anyone doing a Queen cover is automatically at a disadvantage because it's. . well, QUEEN. But the intent behind it makes it very cool for me to listen to anyway.
"Some day, one day. . . "
|
Brian_Mays_Wig
Deity: 2934 posts
|
Richard Orchard wrote: I really think that you guys are unrealistic in your expectations. it is as though the cover doesn't sound "exactly" like Queen it is bad. Here here. sounds fine to me. If that was my band, id be proud.
Chom own mudder fukker.
|
Adam Baboolal
Deity: 4995 posts
|
Yup, definitely glad that there are fan covers coming back. Now, it's not about whether it sounds like Queen or not. It's about: a) Does it sound good? and b) Does it have feeling? To me, it just doesn't have feeling. It's like listening to a band who are just doing it because of the song's status. Sorry, that's how I see it. There's nothing wrong with it, sonically, but the playing and the singing just don't do it for me. And I'm the kind of person that can appreciate a cover in straight or altered form. It really doesn't matter for me. Peace, Adam.
|
inu-liger
Deity: 13107 posts
|
It's not very good. But then I can't complain, because I've been waiting a LONG time to hear some new cover material :P
|
Zander05
Bohemian: 860 posts
|
Just had a fresh listen (listened to the whole thing too). With a song like this, I think it's essential to have sort of the Elvis voice like Freddie did. This cover just does not agree with me. But I also commend them for trying.
|
